1 Yogi Berra – New York Yankees

2 Sid Gordon – Boston Braves

3 Ferris Fain – Philadelphia Athletics

4 Vern Stephens – Boston Red Sox
5 Phil Rizzuto – New York Yankees
6 Allie Reynolds – New York Yankees
7 Howie Pollet – St. Louis Cardinals
8 Early Wynn – Cleveland Indians
9 Roy Sievers – St. Louis Browns
10 Mel Parnell – Boston Red Sox
11 Gene Hermanski – Brooklyn Dodgers
12 Jim Hegan – Cleveland Indians
13 Dale Mitchell – Cleveland Indians
14 Wayne Terwilliger – Chicago Cubs
15 Ralph Kiner – Pittsburgh Pirates
16 Preacher Roe – Brooklyn Dodgers
17 Dave Bell – Pittsburgh Pirates
18 Jerry Coleman – New York Yankees
19 Dick Kokos – St. Louis Browns
20 Dom DiMaggio – Boston Red Sox
21 Larry Jansen – New York Giants
22 Bob Feller – Cleveland Indians
23 Ray Boone – Cleveland Indians
24 Hank Bauer – New York Yankees
25 Cliff Chambers – Pittsburgh Pirates
26 Luke Easter – Cleveland Indians
27 Wally Westlake – Pittsburgh Pirates

28 Elmer Valo – Philadelphia Athletics

29 Bob Kennedy – Cleveland Indians

30 Warren Spahn – Boston Braves
31 Gil Hodges – Brooklyn Dodgers
32 Hank Thompson – New York Giants
33 Bill Werle – Pittsburgh Pirates
34 Grady Hatton – Cincinnati Reds
35 Al Rosen – Cleveland Indians

36 Gus Zernial – Chicago White Sox

36 Gus Zernial – Philadelphia Athletics
37 Wes Westrum – New York Giants
38 Duke Snider – Brooklyn Dodgers
39 Ted Kluszewski – Cincinnati Reds
40 Mike Garcia – Cleveland Indians
41 Whitey Lockman – New York Giants
42 Ray Scarborough – Boston Red Sox
43 Maurice McDermott – Boston Red Sox
44 Sid Hudson – Washington Senators
45 Andy Seminick – Philadelphia Phillies
46 Billy Goodman – Boston Red Sox
47 Tommy Glaviano – St. Louis Cardinals
48 Eddie Stanky – New York Giants
49 Al Zarilla – Chicago White Sox
50 Monte Irvin – New York Giants
51 Eddie Robinson – Chicago White Sox
52 Tommy Holmes – Boston Braves
52 Tommy Holmes – Hartford Chiefs